We’ve recently had the chance to visit a few brewpubs in upstate New York.  A couple weeks ago, we went to Bandwagon Brewpub in Ithaca.  Their menu was somewhat limited at about a dozen entrees, but did have some interesting options — and I loved the cornmeal waffles with shrimp and andouille sausage.  We got a flight of Bandwagon’s beers, which packed a few surprises:
- Raspberry Jalapeño: I initially dismissed this as a novelty chili beer, but found it pretty enjoyable. Â The raspberry was more creamy than tart, and there was just a little chili heat.
- Ezra Red Ale: Very hoppy aroma, but pretty mild and even a little sweet. Â Nothing wrong with it, but not really winning me over either.
- High Step Weizenbock: Like a sweeter hefeweizen. Â By this point in the flight, I was starting to wonder at liking the novelty beer best.
- Pirate Eye PA: Very sharp resin. Â I’m not a big IPA fan, but I found this undrinkable.
- Sully’s Irish Stout: Smoky and dry. Â I’ve warmed to stout recently, especially malty imperial stout. Â But this is a very dry Irish stout, which I just didn’t enjoy much at all.
So their food was good, if not a ton of options. Â And none of the beers really captured my imagination, though the Raspberry Jalapeño and High Step Weizenbock were both pretty good. Â So I had a great time, but I probably won’t be drinking any more of their beer. Â In fact, we took the kids there for lunch last week, but we got beers from other NY breweries.
One of those breweries is Rooster Fish from Watkins Glen. Â We drove over to Corning to see the excellent glass museum and were driving through Watkins Glen on our way back and stopped for lunch. Â They had a much bigger menu, with a lot of good options to agonize over, even for the kids. Â Instead of having a pre-set flight, they let you get samples of as many beers as you want. Â The next table had a couple with samples of all 12, but we stuck with just 5:
- Aspen Wit: a nice and spicy hefeweizen, reminding me of some of the better spicy/herbal German hefeweizen we tried.
- Summer Sky: much more tart and clean.
- Tripel Witch: probably my least favorite of the bunch, this tripel was reedy and herbal, reminding me of some of the tripels we tried and didn’t like.
- Mysterious Amber: tons of toffee and caramel, almost a little too sweet, but very nice for a malt-lover like me.
- Scotch Ale: very peaty and smoky, a wonderful wee heavy that isn’t too sweet or chewy. Â Ranks right up with my favorites. Â We picked up a growler of this to take home.
So it was a much nicer experience all the way around. Â Of the beers we tried from the two breweries, I think I liked my least favorite from Rooster Fish (the tripel) as much as my favorite from Bandwagon. Â







