We’ve had a couple of pumpkin beers this fall, and picked up a few more in Asheville last weekend, so we had a little side-by-side tasting.
-
Thirsty Dog’s Pumpkin Ale. This surprised me at how light-bodied it was, since I generally expect fall seasonal beers to be malty, dark, or both. But this was almost like a pilsner, with a little twang. The pumpkin taste was very subdued. But overall, I’d say this is nice, and easy-drinking.
-
Southern Tier’s Pumking. This brew had a definite pumpkin aroma, but the flavor was overwhelmed by vanilla and spice. In fact, I had a hard time picking up anything else. Wind likes this much more than I do, and the ratings online are pretty high, but I find it just barely drinkable, and not very pumpkiny at all.
-
Cigar City’s Good Gourd. This is my idea of what a pumpkin beer should be, with definite spice and vanilla notes, but not overwhelming the pumpkin flavor. This beer has a little more sweetness and body, and has the highest ABV at 9.5%.
-
Starr Hill Boxcar Pumpkin Porter. A decent porter, if a little thin. Unfortunately, the pumpkin is drowned out by over-strong smoke and coffee. Finishes a little too bitter, but with more pumpkin at least.
Overall, I’m a little disappointed. I expected beers with pumpkin in the name to have a more pronounced pumpkin flavor. Only the Good Gourd met my expectations on that score, and is definitely my favorite of the bunch. The Thirsty Dog Pumpkin Ale would be the runner up, and I’m definitely glad I picked up a bottle when I had the chance.